Australian Artists From Paul Kelly to Jimmy Barnes Take On Big AI Over Copyright
Paul Kelly, Jimmy Barnes and Peter Garrett are confronting the Albanese government over AI copyright loopholes. Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young warns Australia risks becoming 'the Cayman Islands of AI'.

Why it matters
- Australian artists including Paul Kelly, Jimmy Barnes, Peter Garrett and Anna Funder publicly challenged the Albanese government this week over AI copyright loopholes.
- Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young says big tech is already building datacentres in Australia, removing the incentive argument for weakening copyright.
- She warns any Australian loophole would give Big AI 'a backdoor to scrape and steal cultural works everywhere, using Australian datacentres'.
- The proposed test for new laws: consent, credit and compensation, rather than an opt-out system for creators.
- First Nations artists are already having work stolen and sold on platforms like Temu without permission or payment, she writes.
Some of the biggest names in Australian music, publishing, journalism and art have thrown down the gauntlet to the Albanese government this week over copyright and AI. Paul Kelly, Jimmy Barnes, Peter Garrett and Anna Funder are all, as Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young puts it, "singing from the same song sheet."
Their message is blunt: "Australia, and our culture, is not AI's to take."
Hanson-Young, a Greens Senator for South Australia, laid out the confrontation in a pointed opinion piece that frames the prime minister's choice in stark terms. In her words, Anthony Albanese must decide whether "he stands with Jimmy Barnes and the Working Class Man or does he stand with Big AI."
What Is Big AI Actually Asking For?
At the center of the dispute is a lobbying push by major technology companies. Hanson-Young writes that Big AI wants "access to the world's vast creative library to train their models." To get it, they are lobbying the Albanese Labor government for loopholes in copyright laws, "so they can scrape and use other people's hard work without having to pay or even ask for permission."
The stakes rest on more than a century of legal tradition. Copyright protections currently give Australian artists control over their own work and the ability to earn a living from it. Hanson-Young argues that weakening those protections would let the world's wealthiest corporations treat Australian stories, photographs and books as free raw material.
The trade being offered, she writes, is a seat at the table of the global AI boom — in exchange for "unfettered access to our cultural treasures and a free pass to avoid the basic notion of property rights."
Why Datacentres Are the Real Story
The copyright fight has a physical anchor: datacentres. These are enormous, power-hungry warehouse facilities packed with the servers that power AI models like ChatGPT. They feed on vast amounts of data, including, as Hanson-Young notes, "Australian music, books, journalism, culture and knowledge."
But her sharpest claim cuts against the usual justification for loosening copyright rules. Big tech is already building datacentres in Australia. The companies want Australian land, Australian water and Australian energy. In her telling, the copyright debate "only exists because Labor is desperate to offer yet another incentive to set up shop here."
That matters because it removes the central bargaining chip. If the datacentre investment is arriving regardless, Hanson-Young argues, then weakening copyright buys Australia nothing — and costs its creative sector dearly. As she puts it: "Australian artists, creatives and journalists shouldn't be the sacrificial lamb to big AI's slaughter."
Who Pays If the Loopholes Pass?
The senator's warning extends well beyond the recording studio. She catalogs the casualties she expects if copyright is weakened:
- Journalists, whose reporting risks being "swallowed by AI models that reproduce their work and compete with their publications."
- Artists, authors, performers and screenwriters, whose work could be used "to churn out AI slop at the expense of their livelihoods."
- First Nations artists, whose work she says is "already having their work stolen and sold on platforms like Temu without permission or payment." She calls it "outrageous that the world's oldest continuing living culture should have to compete with computer servers."
- Everyday Australians, anyone who "has shared a photo, story or artwork online" and could have it scraped and fed into commercial AI systems without their knowledge or consent.
Could Australia Become 'the Cayman Islands of AI'?
Hanson-Young's most memorable warning is about global spillover. For AI companies, she writes, "this is a global play with big consequences." Any copyright loopholes Australia creates will undermine protections worldwide. Big AI would gain "a backdoor to scrape and steal cultural works everywhere, using Australian datacentres."
Other countries, she notes, have read the writing on the wall. They are strengthening copyright laws to protect their own culture and stop big AI from exploiting their legal systems. Her conclusion: "Australia can't afford to be the weak link in the chain."
The alternative she sketches is unflattering. "We risk becoming the Cayman Islands of AI, a safe haven for big tech — a global pariah riddled with loopholes where AI can exploit culture and knowledge and dodge the laws that protect it."
What Is the Test for the Prime Minister?
Albanese has promised to do the right thing by Australian creators. Hanson-Young's response: "words are cheap." The test, she writes, is whether his laws guarantee three things:
- Consent — creators asked before their work is used.
- Credit — their authorship recognized.
- Compensation — payment for the use of their work.
She rejects outright an opt-out system, one that "forces artists, freelancers and small newsrooms to chase billion-dollar tech companies to protect their rights." The asymmetry is the point. Individual creators and small publishers cannot litigate against the largest corporations on earth, session after session, just to keep what copyright law already grants them.
Why This Fight Matters Beyond Australia
The piece closes on cultural grounds rather than legal ones. Hanson-Young describes Australian music, films and art as "our memories, our connections to each other, our heartbreaks and our identity – the story of our nation." Her final line is a refusal: "It's not a bargaining chip for big AI and they are not AI's to take."
The confrontation lands at a moment when governments worldwide are wrestling with how training data, intellectual property and AI investment fit together. Australia's decision on consent, credit and compensation will signal to other jurisdictions whether a middle-sized economy can hold the line on creator rights — or whether datacentre investment can buy a rewrite of a century of copyright law. With artists of this stature publicly mobilized, the Albanese government will find the loophole route far harder to sell at home, whatever the lobbying pressure behind it.
Sarah Hanson-Young is a Greens Senator for South Australia.
Source: The Guardian AI
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Market editor covering technology and product news in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.
795 articles
Related articles
- Paul Kelly demands Albanese 'show some backbone' as AI copyright fight hits Australia
- Albanese's Own Electorate Revolts Over AI Copyright Scraping Plan
- Australia’s AI Copyright Debate Faces a Section 51 Test
- Australia's AI copyright plan would create 'IP-laundering paradise', UK group warns
- IFPI warns Australia against 'ridiculous and dangerous' AI copyright weakening