Policy & Regulation

Paul Kelly demands Albanese 'show some backbone' as AI copyright fight hits Australia

Paul Kelly, Jimmy Barnes and Peter Garrett back the Not AI's To Take campaign as AI firms push to loosen Australian copyright law before legislation due by early 2027.

Paul Kelly pleads for Albanese to ‘show some backbone’ over AI as creatives campaign for copyright protections
Paul Kelly pleads for Albanese to ‘show some backbone’ over AI as creatives campaign for copyright protectionsAI-generated
By James Calloway6 min read

Why it matters

  • Australia's creative industry is worth $70bn and employs 600,000 workers, per campaign figures
  • AI legislation package expected late 2026 or early 2027, covering datacentres, online safety, productivity and copyright
  • More than 100 court cases involving copyright and AI training are on foot in the US, per senator David Pocock
  • Anthropic proposed an opt-out model and told a Senate committee it would provide model access to Australian entities regardless of training permission
  • Not AI's To Take is backed by Aria, the Copyright Agency, Foxtel, Nine, Seven and Guardian Australia among others

Paul Kelly, Jimmy Barnes and Peter Garrett are backing a campaign demanding the Albanese government refuse to weaken Australian copyright law as AI companies lobby for looser rules on training data. The campaign, called Not AI's To Take, launched ahead of Wednesday night's Aria awards with support from dozens of creative groups across recording, writing, publishing, film, television and media.

The stakes are large and quantified. Australia's creative industry generates $70bn and employs 600,000 workers, according to figures cited by the campaigning organisations, who argue that changes to copyright law could put both at risk.

Kelly's message to the government is blunt. "Australia has had some of the best copyright laws, something to be proud of. Now is the time for our government to show some backbone," the songwriter said in quotes shared on the campaign's website. Barnes was less diplomatic: "I think that these companies should go and f..k themselves."

What is the government actually proposing?

The government is expected to unveil a long-awaited legislative package on AI in late 2026 or early 2027, covering datacentres, online safety, productivity and copyright. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said last week that artists "need to be compensated if their work is used" and has previously declared it would be "theft" if creatives went unpaid.

Industry minister Tim Ayres said on Tuesday that "nothing has changed in terms of the government's approach" to copyright. "We're not about undermining copyright here. That commitment has been made so many times now," he said.

Yet Ayres also acknowledged industry pressure points, saying "the status quo is no good" for creative workers. "I understand the anxiety, though. For those workers, the status quo is no good for them. Their work is currently being appropriated, today, offshore. We have set out a program for a scheme of legislation that would protect those rights, make sure that artificial intelligence investment in Australia is on Australia's terms," Ayres said.

A spokesperson for attorney general Michelle Rowland said the government was "committed to supporting" creatives and pledged that any copyright changes would "deliver meaningful control and fair compensation." The phrase "any copyright changes" is doing quiet work in that sentence; the commitment presupposes changes will come.

The takeaway: the government promises protection while declining to rule out amendment, which is precisely the ambiguity the campaign wants closed.

Who is behind Not AI's To Take?

The campaign counts among its backers:

  • Aria, Australia's recording industry body
  • The Copyright Agency
  • The Australian Directors' Guild
  • Screen Producers Australia
  • The Australian Society of Authors
  • The Australian Writers' Guild
  • Media organisations including Foxtel, Free TV, Nine, Seven and Guardian Australia

Musicians Montaigne and KLP have backed the campaign online, while Guardian Australia understands Barnes, Kelly and Garrett — some of Albanese's favourite musicians — will also feature in it.

KLP, real name Kristy Lee Peters, framed the ask as continuity rather than confrontation. "Our government has been a huge supporter of Australian music and creativity, and now we're asking them to continue that support by standing firm on copyright and making sure big tech doesn't get to rewrite the rules at the expense of creators," she said.

The campaign's scale matters politically: it spans the music industry, publishing, screen production and the country's largest commercial broadcasters, a coalition with reach into almost every electorate.

What do AI companies want?

Some AI companies have argued it is too difficult to make individual licensing deals under existing copyright law. They say they need legal certainty on the copyright question before investing and training models in Australia.

Anthropic has put forward an "opt-out" model that would allow the scraping of creative works by default unless a rightsholder objected — an inversion of consent that puts the administrative burden on creators rather than the companies using their work.

But Anthropic's own testimony to a Senate committee cuts against the argument that legal certainty is a precondition for operating in Australia. The company told the committee it would "provide ongoing access to frontier models to eligible Australian entities, regardless of whether training is permitted." In plain terms: the models would be available either way.

Dean Ormston, CEO of music rights organisation Apra Amcos, said the AI platforms have never engaged directly. "[AI platforms] haven't made one phone call yet. They haven't called us. They haven't called anybody," he said. "There's nothing wrong with the copyright framework. The problem is getting somebody to sit at the table and have a discussion with us."

Is copyright law the problem, or is enforcement?

The campaign's core argument is that the law is fine and enforcement is lacking. Creatives argue copyright law doesn't need updating — just better enforcement. Patrizia Di Biase-Dyson, CEO of the Australian Publishers Association, rejected the suggestion the campaign was an attack on AI firms.

"This isn't a smear campaign. We're just making some noise out in the open, where tech companies are doing it in the shadows," she said. "Everything is at stake. We have to do as much as possible to educate everyone."

Ormston said creative industries welcomed AI investment and opportunities, and had applauded Labor's rebuffing of a proposed text and data mining exemption (a rule that would have allowed copying of copyrighted works for AI training without permission) as well as Albanese's public support. But artists remain worried about potential changes.

"Our very clear message to the government has been: hold firm. You are absolutely saying the right thing. You are absolutely right in the fact that while we want AI in this country, we want it on Australia's terms," Ormston said.

The takeaway: the industry's position is not anti-AI; it is pro-licensing, and it disputes that the current framework blocks negotiation rather than merely lacking willing counterparties.

Could Australia become a 'data laundering hotspot'?

Independent senator David Pocock urged caution, warning that poorly drafted copyright changes could create a legal "loophole" making Australia a global "data laundering hotspot" — a jurisdiction where copyrighted material could effectively be cleaned of its origin through mass ingestion into training sets.

Pocock pointed to the United States as evidence for waiting. "There are more than 100 court cases on foot involving copyright and AI training in the US and we should wait for these to play out before making any changes given the risks of getting it wrong are so high," he said.

That count gives the legislative timeline its sharpest tension: Australia's package is due in late 2026 or early 2027, while the US litigation that could clarify the legal terrain may still be unresolved. The government would be legislating ahead of, not behind, the jurisprudence.

The takeaway: the debate is no longer whether AI training uses creative work, but whether Australia writes its rules before the courts define anyone's.

What happens next?

The creative community's concern is that lobbying from big tech may sway government decisions between now and the legislative package's release. The campaign's implicit bet is that public pressure — Kelly calling for backbone, Barnes offering blunter phrasing — can outweigh private lobbying whose content remains undisclosed.

The government's repeated assurances have not yet been matched by draft text, and Ayres's remark that "the status quo is no good" leaves open what, exactly, he intends to change. Until the bill is published, both sides are arguing over a document neither has seen — and the 600,000 workers in the $70bn sector will learn the terms only when Canberra chooses to show them.

Original: instagram.com

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

722 articles

Related articles

  1. Australia’s AI Copyright Debate Faces a Section 51 Test
  2. Albanese's Own Electorate Revolts Over AI Copyright Scraping Plan
  3. Anthropic asks Australia for opt-out AI copyright model as ABC objects
  4. Australia's AI copyright plan would create 'IP-laundering paradise', UK group warns
  5. Elton John Warns Australia: Don't Let AI Take Artists' Work

« Previous articleNext article »