Society & Ethics

Israel uploaded 3.5m photos of Palestinians to Amazon Rekognition

Leaked documents reviewed by The Guardian show Israel uploaded 3.5 million photos of Palestinians to Amazon Rekognition in early 2024, expanding AWS ties at the center of Gaza surveillance.

Revealed: Israel uploaded millions of photos to Amazon’s facial recognition platform to track Palestinians
Revealed: Israel uploaded millions of photos to Amazon’s facial recognition platform to track PalestiniansPexels / pixabay
By Marcus Bennett7 min read

Why it matters

  • The Israeli military uploaded 3.5 million Palestinian images to Amazon Rekognition in early 2024.
  • Rolling Stone moved significant data into an AWS walled garden throughout 2023.
  • Project Nimbus dates to 2021 and is a multibillion-dollar AWS-Google contract for government and military cloud services.
  • AWS opened new Israeli datacentres in early 2023, while a large proportion of data also moved from AWS datacentres in Ireland.
  • A small group of Israeli soldiers worked from AWS’s 28th-floor Tel Aviv office in early 2024.

By Marcus Bennett

The Israeli military uploaded 3.5 million photographs of Palestinians to Amazon’s Rekognition image-analysis platform in early 2024, according to leaked documents reviewed by The Guardian. The transfer placed a large identity archive inside Amazon Web Services (AWS), the cloud-computing arm of the company founded by billionaire Jeff Bezos. The military department notified Amazon in early 2024 that it intended to use Rekognition, Amazon’s AI-powered image-analysis platform, in a facial-recognition project, the documents show. The timing matters because the catalogue entered Amazon’s cloud during the early months of Israel’s aerial bombardment and ground offensive in Gaza, according to The Guardian. The stakes extend beyond one upload. The Guardian reported that Project Nimbus, a multibillion-dollar 2021 AWS-Google government contract, governs sensitive military computing and restricts when the companies can suspend Israeli clients.

What did Israel upload to Amazon’s cloud?

Rolling Stone, a department within a military software unit, moved the image set into an AWS datacentre near Tel Aviv, according to the leaked documents. The department takes its name from a system that the military uses as a central repository of information about Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank.

At the time, several sources with knowledge of the department’s work said Rolling Stone was exploring facial-recognition technologies for its extensive catalogues of Palestinian images. The military’s collection includes photographs associated with the population registries it controls.

The files and interviews with military sources indicate that Israel moved more than images into Amazon’s datacentres over several years. The Guardian reported that the migrated material included sensitive intelligence and information about Palestinians living under occupation.

AWS infrastructure also supported the collection and processing of personal data that The Guardian described as typically gathered indiscriminately, through intrusive means and without consent. That puts scrutiny on AWS’s role in population-scale surveillance rather than on a single image-matching trial.

Rolling Stone appears to be one of AWS’s most significant Israeli military clients, the documents suggest. Files show the department transferred substantial data into a segregated AWS area during 2023, expanding its use of cloud storage and analysis services.

A military source involved in the transfer told The Guardian:

“The plan [at Rolling Stone] was to migrate pictures, videos, all the confidential intelligence information – everything.”

The source spoke on condition of anonymity. The plan would have moved the department’s databases from military servers into AWS, including its image and video holdings and confidential intelligence.

Rolling Stone oversees several expansive databases on Palestinians, including the system from which the branch takes its name. According to the files and The Guardian’s reporting, the system has operated for decades and updates continually with:

  • Basic personal and family details.
  • Property holdings.
  • Checkpoint crossings.
  • Work permits.
  • Criminal activity.

According to The Guardian, Israel’s control of population registries in Gaza and the West Bank has allowed the department to amass millions of photographs taken for identity cards issued to every resident at 16. Sources familiar with the work said the military routinely used those images in facial-recognition programs.

One program is Blue Wolf, a smartphone app Israeli soldiers use in the West Bank to scan faces and retrieve information, including whether a person has been flagged for arrest. Face scanning is routine at checkpoints, and custom-built smartphone apps collect images across the territory, according to The Guardian.

A soldier told Breaking the Silence, an Israeli nongovernmental organization, in 2016 that Rolling Stone centralized information relevant to controlling the Palestinian civilian population. The account predates the AWS transfer, but it documents the system’s longstanding purpose.

How did AWS become part of the military system?

The foundation is Project Nimbus, a sweeping 2021 contract under which AWS and Google provide cloud services to a wide range of government and military clients. The Guardian described the deal as multibillion-dollar and reported unusual terms that prevent the US companies from restricting or suspending Israeli government or military use, even after a terms-of-service breach.

Those clauses would prevent the unilateral response Microsoft took in the previous year, when it disabled Israeli military access to technology used for a mass-surveillance system exposed by The Guardian and +972 Magazine. Under the contract, cloud access can continue even when Israel breaches a provider’s terms.

AWS opened new datacentres in Israel in early 2023 under Nimbus, allowing government and military clients to migrate data from their own servers. Documents also show that a large proportion of data moved from AWS datacentres in Ireland.

Project Nimbus obliged AWS to provide the Israeli military access to a segregated area inside its Tel Aviv datacentres. The area carries enhanced digital and physical security and stores sensitive material on military operations and intelligence collection; AWS and its client call it a walled garden.

The walled garden gave the military a way to combine rapidly scalable storage, computing power and AI-driven services from major US technology providers. The Guardian characterized this reliance as part of Israel’s broader embrace of leading US companies to meet the technological demands of war.

What happened at Gaza’s checkpoints?

Israel has long used facial recognition, particularly in the West Bank. In the early stages of its Gaza campaign, the military used Rekognition to identify hostages captured by militants in the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on 7 October 2023.

It also deployed facial recognition to identify people suspected of being militants. The New York Times previously reported that the military tested commercial technology in Gaza to detect faces in crowds and drone footage, sometimes wrongly flagging civilians as militants.

After the ground invasion in October 2023, the military routinely collected images of Palestinians passing through checkpoints, often after the bombing campaign had forcibly displaced them. A military source said AWS infrastructure served those sites because of the very large scale of the collected images.

It remains unclear whether the 3.5 million photographs uploaded to Rekognition came from checkpoint collection. The Guardian described the checkpoints as effective pop-up surveillance posts.

At temporary Israeli checkpoints in Gaza, cameras trained on approaching Palestinians captured their images. Sources said facial-recognition systems then matched those images against records held in Rolling Stone’s systems.

The checkpoints became notorious for detentions, The Guardian reported. Many Palestinians taken into Israeli custody were held without communication, which several United Nations bodies and rights groups characterized as enforced disappearances.

Documents suggest AWS cloud technology supported checkpoint work at times during 2024. Israeli soldiers referred to the sites by the Hebrew word Nakaz, which means drainage, according to The Guardian.

What do AWS and the IDF say?

In early 2024, a small group of Israeli soldiers worked from AWS’s Tel Aviv office on the 28th floor of one of Israel’s tallest skyscrapers. Several military sources said they explored ways to use AWS infrastructure to operate the facial-recognition program underway in Gaza more effectively.

The sources did not establish whether the team’s work became operational or connected to the 3.5 million-image upload. The Guardian said the soldiers’ presence nevertheless underscored a close relationship between the military and AWS.

An AWS spokesperson said the company had no visibility into workloads held by customers in its cloud. The spokesperson then said:

“We respect the privacy of our customers, and we do not discuss our relationship without their consent.”

The spokesperson also said customers regularly visit AWS offices for briefings and meetings. The spokesperson described any suggestion that the soldiers’ visits were not routine customer engagement as wrong and unsubstantiated.

An Israel Defence Forces spokesperson said the military did not intend to comment on engagements or services related to operational needs. The IDF therefore supplied no public account of the soldiers’ work, the upload or the 2024 checkpoint deployments.

The documents suggest AWS ties deepened during a period in which Israel faced accusations of grave crimes in Gaza, including genocide. Israel denies the genocide charge; a United Nations commission of inquiry, Israeli human-rights groups and genocide experts support it, according to The Guardian.

Scrutiny of AI’s role in the offensive has intensified since the release of NAZA, a Guardian-produced documentary about the remote surveillance and killing of Palestinian civilians. Guardian producer Harry Davies was one of its producers, and Yuval Abraham co-directed it. The documentary reached cinemas worldwide and was scheduled for a free Guardian website stream in early December.

The documents leave the central technical claim unresolved: the 3.5 million-image upload is documented, but the soldiers’ facial-recognition work is not shown to have become operational. For AWS, the parallel issue is contractual, because Nimbus limits suspension even after an Israeli client breaches service terms. Evidence on either point would establish how deeply the cloud pilot became routine military infrastructure.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

718 articles

Related articles

  1. Amazon Starts Selling AI Models Built From Rat Brain Cells
  2. Israel Launches National AI Institute Targeting Up to 14 Missions a Year
  3. Nol8 launches AI Data Plane with 1 GB/s deterministic inspection
  4. US Quietly Pulled a Chinese AI Tool the FBI Calls Malicious
  5. Amazon warns communities: block AI data centers, risk the economy

« Previous articleNext article »