Society & Ethics

AI Can Produce Stories. Humans Still Give Them Meaning

At a Friday Seoul forum, veteran creators said AI can produce average stories, while games still need narrative purpose, emotional friction and a core that survives adaptation.

'Like novels and films, games also hinge on the story they tell'
'Like novels and films, games also hinge on the story they tell'jamesmarkosborne / pixabay
By Elena Vasquez6 min read

Why it matters

  • Three veteran creators spoke at Friday’s forum at PUBG Seongsu in Seoul.
  • Lee Woo-hyuk’s “Toemarok” became a live-action film in 1998 and an animated feature in 2025.
  • Lee Jun-young said AI can make average-quality stories, while distinctly human stories attract attention.
  • The panel cited “Project Zomboid” and “World of Warcraft” as examples of narrative-driven game design.
  • Byun Young-joo adapted Miyabe Miyuki’s “Helpless” while preserving what she called the author’s attitude.

By Elena Vasquez

Director Byun Young-joo told a Friday forum at PUBG Seongsu in Seoul: “AI can be a useful paintbrush, but what matters is what kind of story you are telling.”

The event took place in Seoul’s Seongdong District. Game Generation, a cultural criticism webzine run by the Game Culture Foundation, organized the discussion.

Its three veteran guests brought stories from novels, film, television and games. Novelist Lee Woo-hyuk is best known for “Toemarok.” Director Byun’s credits include “Helpless” and the drama series “Queen Mantis.” Lee Jun-young is the CEO of Dreamotion and creator of “My Little Puppy.”

The forum gave the gaming industry a place to hear how creators in other cultural fields approach storytelling. Lee Jun-young and Byun are avid gamers, and both offered candid, concrete advice to game makers.

The central issue was not whether AI can generate words or images. It was whether automated production can replace the human judgment that gives a story purpose, emotional force and a clear point of view.

Can AI replace a human storyteller?

Lee set a wider boundary around the technology. “Can artificial intelligence (AI) provide answers to the problems of human society? We ourselves cannot even answer the fundamental question of what it means to be human,” he said.

The veteran creators had spent decades working through those questions in their work, and they expressed little belief that AI could replace human creativity in narrative writing.

Lee, best known for his “Toemarok” series, said AI might produce rudimentary stories. Stories that address deeper questions, however, ultimately require a human touch.

Byun drew a distinction between utility and authorship. She called AI a “paintbrush,” but argued that the kind of story matters more than the tool. She also described the AI-generated videos flooding social media platforms as closer to parody than genuine creative work.

Lee Jun-young made a similar argument about audience attention. “AI may be able to produce stories of average quality quite well, but I believe that distinctly human stories that move people’s hearts will ultimately attract attention,” he said.

Their position was not that AI has no role in creative work. It was that average output does not settle the questions that narrative writing exists to ask, and that audiences still reward work with a distinct human perspective.

Why do games still need a story?

Lee Jun-young focused on a structural problem in games: their rules limit what players can do. That makes narrative elements a practical tool for explaining constraints and helping players understand and internalize them.

“In a game like ‘Project Zomboid,’ the protagonist can die pointlessly, even because of a bug. But a single narrative line — ‘This is a story about you dying’ — puts those questions to rest,” he said.

The example gives a technical failure a place in the player’s experience. A death caused by a bug can feel random during play, while the framing line makes it part of the larger story the game tells the player.

That is why the panel insisted on carefully developed stories even amid concern that narrative has become less important in games. A clear frame can turn an arbitrary rule or event into something coherent, and that coherence helps a player remain inside the experience.

Lee also praised the development of antagonistic factions. He cited “World of Warcraft,” where the conflict between the Alliance and the Horde creates a compelling dynamic that deepens players’ immersion.

The two examples address different jobs for narrative. “Project Zomboid” uses one line to absorb confusion, while “World of Warcraft” builds a sustained conflict that gives players a reason to care about the world around them.

Does instant satisfaction weaken a story?

Byun raised a separate concern about what she called “cathartic” narratives. In her view, these stories aim to deliver instant gratification to audiences rather than make them wait through difficult material.

“These days, creators face considerable pressure to ‘make me feel satisfied,’” Byun said. “But what drives audiences to identify with a protagonist, worry about them and root for them is often the frustrating, difficult stretch of the story.”

Byun tied audience attachment to the frustrating part of a story. She said emotional investment grows when an audience cannot resolve the protagonist’s situation with instant comfort.

For game makers, that tension matters because stories also organize player expectations. A narrative can explain the stakes of a system and make a difficult sequence feel intentional instead of arbitrary.

Byun’s warning also sat beside the panel’s AI discussion. Creators still have to choose between immediate satisfaction and the frustration that can deepen audience attachment, even while AI-generated videos flood social media platforms.

Can political pressure change the work?

Byun also addressed political pressure surrounding works such as the film “Assassins” and the game “Call of Duty.” She said she did not think creators would be intimidated by that pressure.

She was more direct about what creators need. “Respect and protection for creators are essential to producing good works,” she said.

The policy stakes are therefore practical rather than abstract. If filmmakers and game developers believe political criticism will decide what they can depict, they may narrow their work before they have tested whether bold storytelling can find an audience.

The audience remains part of that calculation. Byun said creators face considerable pressure to satisfy viewers immediately, yet she also said viewers attach themselves to protagonists precisely when the story withholds easy satisfaction for long enough to matter.

What survives when a story changes medium?

The final part of the discussion moved from AI and audience pressure to intellectual property adapted across genres and media. Lee and Byun described two different tests for keeping a story intact while changing its form.

Lee has seen his “Toemarok” series adapted into a live-action film in 1998 and an animated feature in 2025. He said details can change depending on the medium as long as the underlying spirit remains intact.

He expressed regret that the 1998 live-action version had failed to preserve that essence. The adaptation changed the story’s form, but Lee’s judgment was that it did not keep the spirit that made the original work itself.

Byun offered a more flexible account from her film adaptation of Japanese novelist Miyabe Miyuki’s “Helpless.” She changed parts of the source material, and the original author supported those changes.

“That was because I did not tamper with the unchangeable destination of the original narrative — the author’s attitude,” Byun said.

Her formulation separates movable details from a fixed center. A director can change parts of the source material while preserving the attitude that gives the source its meaning.

Together, the examples give game makers a practical standard for AI-assisted production. Generated material can aid the work, but it still needs to clarify rules, deepen immersion and preserve the attitude at the story’s core.

As AI-generated media becomes more common, the panel’s test remains concrete: the result must make a player understand the world, feel the conflict and recognize the human judgment behind the story.

Source: feed.koreatimes.co.kr

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

708 articles

Related articles

  1. Raphael brings polished AI visuals, but a familiar plot
  2. AI CEOs Keep Pitching a Future Nobody Asked For
  3. Google's AI Playground Builds Playable Games From Prompts—Mostly
  4. MIT stranded Claude on a virtual island for 30 hours. It played.
  5. Marissa Mayer's AI Parenting Pitch Sparks a Reckoning Over Tech Execs

« Previous articleNext article »