Policy & Regulation

Australia’s defence bill could shield AI contractors from Australian law

Tom Sulston says a rushed Australian defence bill would exempt contractors from domestic law and create security zones around datacentres, sharpening questions over AI, military work and oversight.

Australia has a reputation for being the most secretive democracy in the world. New laws could make it worse | Tom Sulst
Australia has a reputation for being the most secretive democracy in the world. New laws could make it worse | Tom SulstTho-Ge / pixabay
By Rebecca Stone7 min read

Why it matters

  • In 2019, The New York Times called Australia “the world’s most secretive democracy”.
  • The bill would let the defence minister grant pre-emptive exemptions to defence officials, including third-party contractors.
  • The bill would create “defence security zones” covering both military and civilian infrastructure.
  • The government announced last week that OpenAI would not face criminal charges over a recent Medicare data breach.
  • The US government treated Anthropic’s “Fable” model as defence materiel and prohibited foreign nationals from using it, according to Sulston.

By Rebecca Stone

Tom Sulston says Australia’s parliament is rushing the accelerating capability and protecting bases bill, which would let the defence minister grant pre-emptive exemptions from Australian law to defence officials, including third-party contractors.

The government has been quiet about the proposal, according to Sulston. He places it in a line of defence, anti-terror and surveillance bills passed under consecutive governments. The New York Times described Australia in 2019 as “the world’s most secretive democracy,” and Sulston says those laws shifted power from parliament toward the executive.

For Sulston, the stakes are legal equality and oversight of companies entering defence supply chains. If exemptions follow contractors into private work, the minister could shield actors from rules that apply to civilians, while national-security rules limit the evidence needed to test those decisions.

What would ministers be allowed to exempt?

Sulston says the bill would broaden the legal category of “defence officials” to include commercial contractors working for the defence department. The defence minister would have discretion to declare staff employed by those corporations eligible for pre-emptive exemptions.

He accepts that defence officials can have legitimate needs that civilians do not. Soldiers, for example, carry automatic weapons that are illegal for the rest of the population, and some defence work may require protections unavailable in ordinary civilian life. His objection concerns where the bill would draw the line around commercial work.

Under Sulston’s reading, a defence contractor could gain the ministerial dispensation previously associated with military duties. He warns that this would allow “mercenaries working for private military contractors to operate in Australia with legal impunity.” The language would place a private security company inside an exemption regime created for the state’s defence apparatus.

He says national-security provisions would also restrict public and parliamentary scrutiny of designations, with heavy punishments for whistleblowers. Those provisions would place ministerial discretion at the centre of the scheme while limiting outside disclosure. Sulston argues that the combination magnifies the risk of unaccountable executive power.

Why do US technology companies matter?

US technology companies have expanded their customer base to include national defence departments. Sulston divides the relevant businesses into three groups:

  • OpenAI and Anthropic, which he describes as AI hyperscalers that now work as defence contractors.
  • Google and Microsoft, which he identifies as cloud providers that now work as defence contractors.
  • Palantir, which he describes as a defence-data specialist and defence contractor.

Their role creates a direct overlap with civilian life, according to Sulston. These firms operate over the internet, the communications infrastructure on which Australian civic life depends. Military work would therefore place commercial AI and cloud providers inside systems that ordinary residents cannot easily inspect.

Sulston also points to the military status of AI products. He says that when Anthropic released its “Fable” model, the US government treated it as defence materiel and prohibited foreign nationals from using it. The episode, as he presents it, shows a commercial model moving into a system of military restrictions.

Where would the systems run?

Sulston says AI corporations need somewhere to host their website-hacking agents. The bill would give the defence minister a mechanism for such sites: “defence security zones.”

Under the powers Sulston describes, the minister could designate both military and civilian infrastructure as deserving special treatment. The public would have neither access nor transparency there. A datacentre operating inside such a designation could function as a commercial site while remaining outside ordinary public oversight.

He uses Pine Gap, a US military listening station, as the clearest example. Australians cannot walk its perimeter or take photographs. Sulston accepts that Pine Gap is a military installation and that the United States is sensitive about it, but he argues that the proposed category can reach civilian and commercial infrastructure.

That distinction matters because AI companies now create military products while their datacentres host products for commercial customers. In Sulston’s account, a commercial operation could acquire the legal opacity associated with Pine Gap without becoming a military installation itself. The status of the operator and the status of the site would no longer be the same question.

Could datacentre protests become criminal matters?

AI corporations are also rushing to construct datacentres in suburban Australia to host their products. Sulston says local residents do not want a massive facility at the end of their road taking their data, electricity or jobs. They also do not want what he calls a commercially operated “mini Pine Gap” that would constitute a military target.

He says opposition to datacentre construction is strong across Australia. The proposed security-zone power would turn that local opposition into a question controlled by the defence minister.

If a datacentre became a “defence security zone,” the federal government could restrict protests and civil disobedience against it. Heavy jail terms would punish disruption. That would allow the government to place a commercial facility under the same national-security framework used for military sites.

Sulston illustrates the stakes with what he calls the “important AI business of making deepfake nudes and targeting missile strikes in Gaza.” His point is not merely that AI infrastructure can attract military attention. A designation could make opposition to the facility itself punishable as interference with national security.

What has the government signaled about enforcement?

Last week, the government announced that OpenAI would not face criminal charges over its recent Medicare data breach. The decision came as the government flagged changes to Australia’s criminal law, which Sulston says should raise a separate question about how those changes would apply to AI companies.

He is more direct about the contradiction he sees. In his account, the government appears willing to accept criminal behaviour by AI companies during what he calls a “desperate scramble for productivity.” At the same time, the defence bill would grant defence-linked AI contractors greater legal protection through national-security exemptions.

This leaves two policy choices in Sulston’s account. One involves deciding whether a recent corporate data breach warrants criminal prosecution. The other involves deciding whether national-security work should exempt defence-linked AI contractors from Australian law and limit scrutiny of the sites where that work runs.

What legal protections are at stake?

Sulston grounds his objection in equality under law, which he calls both a fundamental human-rights principle and part of Australia’s core values of fairness and mateship. He does not argue that every defence activity should carry the same legal rules as civilian work. He argues that private firms should not gain military-style immunity merely because the defence department hires them.

His prescribed remedy is stronger protection for civilians, not broader immunity for contractors. “Instead of granting special dispensation to harm us, our government needs to strengthen legal protection for civilians,” he writes. That position would place legal safeguards around civilian activity ahead of exemptions for state-linked and commercial defence work.

He also calls Australia’s lack of a human rights act urgent. Without legally recognised and enforceable rights, Sulston writes, civilians live in what he calls a dystopian world built for corporate AI profit and blessed by the government. His argument targets the absence of enforceable protections, not only the powers contained in the current bill.

He ends with the internet’s transformation from the “world’s town square” into what he calls a theatre of war. He says people who remember its civic role are grieving over military corporations taking control of that shared space. The military-business relationship at the centre of the defence bill is therefore also a test of who sets the rules for digital infrastructure.

If parliament passes the bill as Sulston describes, Australia will combine ministerial exemptions for defence-linked AI contractors with security zones around military and civilian infrastructure, leaving parliamentary oversight and legal equality as the decisive test.

Original: nytimes.com

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

754 articles

Related articles

  1. Australia to Create AI Safety Regulator With Penalty Powers
  2. Harvey clears IRAP PROTECTED-level assessment for Australian government work
  3. A1 launches Guardrails for mid-market AI governance
  4. Albanese's Own Electorate Revolts Over AI Copyright Scraping Plan
  5. Labor weighs law changes after OpenAI agent hacked Medicare

« Previous articleNext article »