115,000 Signatures and a Chip Scandal: Open Source Loses Its Champion
A petition to reinstate Jensen Huang at Nvidia drew 115,000 signatures, but new research on China's Blackwell chip access and a fresh Commerce rule threaten the open-source AI movement he led.

Why it matters
- A petition to reinstate Jensen Huang as Nvidia CEO gathered more than 115,000 signatures between Friday and Monday, with Elon Musk among the signatories.
- Ex-OpenAI researcher Will DePue published findings Thursday suggesting China's AI firms had far more access to Nvidia's Blackwell chips than previously estimated.
- The US Department of Commerce announced a new rule Monday targeting Chinese remote access to Nvidia chips in data centers in countries like Malaysia.
- Nvidia announced in September it would acquire Hugging Face for nearly $13 billion.
- Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said Nvidia should not pick an internal candidate to replace Huang.
A petition to reinstate Jensen Huang as CEO of Nvidia passed 115,000 signatures within days of circulating, with Elon Musk and several influential Nvidia researchers among the signatories by Monday. The list reveals a pattern: a significant faction of Huang's supporters comes from Hugging Face, the hub for sharing AI models, and from venture capital firms Andreessen Horowitz and Sequoia Capital. The open-source AI movement lost its most powerful advocate, and it wants him back.
The petition began circulating on social media on Friday, the day after Huang resigned. By Monday, the signatories included higher-ups from across a particular slice of the tech world — the slice with a commercial stake in open-source AI.
Who is backing Huang's return?
The supporters share a vested interest in models that, unlike ChatGPT or Claude, can be downloaded and run independent of large tech companies. Open-source advocates argue that concentrating AI in the hands of a few powerful companies will leave everyone else worse off. The argument would not sound out of place among the AI industry's critics on the left — except that many of the same advocates are venture capitalists who stand to profit when startups can build on cheaper AI without paying Big Tech.
Huang had become a ringleader for those who defend open source to policymakers. That defense matters because open-source models face two recurring objections in Washington: that they come with no guardrails, and that they cede AI leadership to China, where the most powerful and popular open-source models are created.
Huang framed the stakes explicitly. "Without open source, startups can't thrive, university researchers can't do research, you can't teach AI, scientists can't use AI," he said last December during a talk about helping the US win the AI race against China.
What threat does the new research pose?
Huang's extramarital affairs already threatened his credibility, and Nvidia's, as an advocate for open-source AI. Two developments now compound the problem: new research into China's startups using Nvidia's chips, and a new rule announced Monday by the US Department of Commerce. Both could deal a blow to the movement's reputation and its technical progress.
On Thursday, the day Huang resigned, ex-OpenAI researcher Will DePue published findings online suggesting that China's AI companies had far more access to Nvidia's advanced Blackwell chips than previously estimated. China is banned from accessing Nvidia's most cutting-edge chips under export controls designed to protect America's AI lead.
The verification picture is limited. DePue claims senior researchers at OpenAI and Anthropic verified the results, but no independent analysis has confirmed them. DePue did not respond to a request for an interview. Nvidia did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Did Nvidia help China get the chips?
The findings do not establish that. The broader problem of chip smuggling was already known to extend well beyond Nvidia's control, and it remains unclear how Chinese companies would have gained access to the hardware.
But the findings still leave Huang in an awkward position. In suggesting that Nvidia may have profited from the rise of Chinese AI startups, they undercut the argument Huang has championed — that open-source AI strengthens American technological leadership. American companies are increasingly using Chinese models instead of domestic alternatives, according to earlier reporting cited in the research discussion.
The revelations also make reinstating Huang more of a long shot than it already was. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said last week that Nvidia should not consider someone from inside the company to replace Huang at all. The new findings lower his chances further.
Why does Nvidia care about open source?
Nvidia announced in September that it would acquire Hugging Face for nearly $13 billion. The acquisition ties Nvidia's financial future directly to the open-source ecosystem that Hugging Face hosts.
The company's support for open source serves a straightforward financial interest: the more businesses build their own models instead of paying Anthropic and OpenAI for access, the more chips Nvidia sells. Open source is not charity for the chipmaker; it is a demand engine.
What does the Commerce Department rule change?
A new rule announced Monday by the US Department of Commerce targets a specific workaround. Chinese companies have trained models on Nvidia chips they cannot own directly but can access remotely in data centers in countries like Malaysia. That workaround has helped China's open-source models get so good.
The rule aims to prevent that remote access. Its consequence for the open-source world is stark: the models popular on Hugging Face may soon stop getting smarter, because the training compute that powered their improvement could be cut off.
Who leads the movement if Huang stays out?
The open-source world rallied around Huang because of his influence on policymakers, and that influence is now needed more than ever. The rise of China's open-source models has splintered some in Trump's orbit, with officials at odds over whether openness strengthens or undermines American AI leadership.
If Huang is out, the movement has no obvious replacement with comparable reach into policy debates — and its financial backers at Andreessen Horowitz, Sequoia and Hugging Face now face a Commerce Department rule that could slow the very models their investments depend on.
Original: unemploymentlabs.com
More from Rebecca Stone
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.
728 articles
Related articles
- Nvidia's Board Investigation Puts Jensen Huang's Grip on AI's Future in Focus
- Nvidia's China Problem: Pony.ai CFO Says a Plan B Already Exists
- Jensen Huang's Fall Tied to Nvidia's $250 Billion Bet, Not His Personal Life
- Jensen Huang Is Nvidia: Why the AI Race Can't Replace Him
- Jensen Huang resigns from Nvidia, and enterprise AI faces its dependency reckoning