UK actors gain digital replica terms in proposed AI pact
Equity’s proposed three-year pact gives UK performers consent and payment rights over digital replicas after a 99% industrial-action ballot, but leaves AI training-data protections unresolved.
Why it matters
- Equity’s three-year proposal requires a vote among 8,000 members, and its leadership recommends approval.
- Members backed industrial action and refusing AI-unprotected scans by 99% in an indicative ballot last December.
- The proposal includes a 24% pay-rate increase for major films and a 9% increase for television projects.
- Actors must approve digital doubles or alterations that make “substantive changes” to agreed nudity or simulated sexual activity scenes.
- Equity says the agreement creates no explicit contractual protection for using performers’ work to train AI systems.
By James Calloway
Equity’s proposed three-year UK film and television pact would give performers consent and payment rights over “digital replicas,” with approval rules for digital doubles and alterations. It covers artificial intelligence (AI) protections and will face a vote among 8,000 members after a 99% industrial-action ballot last December. Equity’s leadership recommends approval.
The proposal also includes a 24% increase in pay rates for major films and a 9% increase for television projects. It remains contingent on the member vote.
What rights do performers gain?
Equity’s summary gives performers two baseline rights: payment when a digital replica is used, and consent to whether it is used. The agreement then sets additional conditions for digital doubles, digital alterations and production stoppages.
- Consent for intimate-scene changes. An actor must approve a digital double or digital alteration used to make “substantive changes” to scenes involving agreed levels of nudity or simulated sexual activity.
- Project-specific permission. The new contract terms require producers to obtain permission for a specific project rather than seek “blanket consent”—advance permission covering unspecified uses—to an actor’s digital replica.
- Strike protection. During a strike, producers may not use a digital replica “in any circumstance where consent is required for such use”.
The payment term is broader than consent alone, because Equity says performers can claim compensation whenever a replica is used. The summary gives no calculation method, usage rate or minimum fee, so the announcement does not establish what a performer would actually receive.
Those provisions give performers a contractual route to control and compensation. Equity’s announcement does not, however, claim that performers own every digital version of their image or performance.
The agreement also leaves “substantive changes” undefined in Equity’s summary. It does not describe an audit process, dispute procedure or penalty for a consent violation, leaving performers to rely on enforcement provisions the announcement does not detail.
Paul W Fleming, Equity’s general secretary, said: “We set about to radically improve and modernise the terms and conditions for performers across UK TV and film. The result is groundbreaking.” He also said: “We’ve achieved the best AI provisions in the business – protecting performers and ensuring that human performance is valued and prioritised across the industry.”
Fleming’s “best AI provisions” claim is the union leader’s assessment, not a comparison tested in the announcement. Equity supplied no benchmark against other film or television agreements, and the agreement itself remains unapproved.
In plain terms, performers gain tighter consent around digital replicas, but key definitions and enforcement details remain unstated.
Why did actors escalate?
The proposed pact follows years of talks with the Producers Alliance for Cinema and Television (Pact), according to Equity. It also follows a growing on-set backlash against AI-related scanning and reuse, which the union cited as pressure behind the agreement.
In an indicative ballot, meaning a vote used to test support rather than finalize a decision, Equity members backed industrial action (organised refusal of work) by 99% last December. They also supported refusing to be scanned on set without further AI protections.
Olivia Williams told The Guardian last year that actors should have as much control over data harvested from body scans as they have over nudity scenes. Williams, a star of Dune: Prophecy and The Crown, said she and other actors were regularly pressed by banks of cameras to undergo scans, with few guarantees about how the data would be used or where it would end up.
Many performers distrust body scans because they fear the data could train AI models on their likenesses or poses. Equity described that risk in terms of technology paving the way to take work away from performers, rather than providing a measured count of jobs already lost.
The announcement does not establish that scan data has produced a specific case of job loss or misuse. Its evidence is an industry dispute shaped by the 99% ballot and performers’ stated lack of trust in current guarantees.
In plain terms, the ballot gave Equity a clear mandate, but the fear over scan data reached beyond the proposed rules for digital replicas.
What does the deal leave unresolved?
Equity said the agreement could not cover every part of production. It specifically identified digital scanning traditionally used for effects added later as an area the new agreement does not cover.
That gap sits beside a more explicit omission. In a note to members, Equity said that “despite our efforts”, the new agreement established no explicit contractual protection for using actors’ performances to train AI systems.
A digital replica is one output from source material. Equity notes that a replica can be made using photography already captured for the production itself, without scanning the artist, so consent to scanning cannot determine every route to a digital replica.
The stated controls focus on handling replicas rather than claiming ownership of them. Producers must limit access to people with a legitimate business need and use “commercially reasonable efforts”—measures a reasonable business would be expected to take—to protect replicas from unauthorized access, use or copying.
“Legitimate business need” is not defined in the announcement, and Equity names no classes of users who automatically qualify. The phrase leaves the permitted circle for access to contract language rather than a published access list.
Equity’s summary does not specify retention periods, technical security standards or penalties for breaching those duties. It also does not explain how training-data use would be handled when production photography contains an actor but no digital replica is created.
The proposal therefore establishes consent and payment for making and using a digital replica, but not an equivalent contractual claim over AI training data (recordings used to train AI systems). In plain terms, the pact advances control over digital doubles without settling who controls the material used to train AI.
What else changes on set?
Beyond AI and digital replicas, the agreement commits producers to safe casting and audition spaces. It also requires training and reporting on sexual harassment, plus adequate hair and makeup provision for artists of all ethnicities and cultures.
Equity did not define what qualifies as safe or adequate in the announcement. The practical force of those commitments therefore depends on terms the announcement does not specify.
The package links those workplace protections to the same three-year deal and its 24% major-film and 9% television pay increases. That gives Equity a broader workplace mandate than an AI clause alone, although the 8,000-member vote still determines adoption.
For producers, project-specific permission changes how they acquire consent and manage replicas across a production. For performers, the deal places payment and approval in the contract instead of relying on a blanket license for digital-image use.
The announcement does not break down what the 24% and 9% increases will cost individual productions. It presents them as general pay terms, not as separate compensation for AI work, so the replica-payment right has no stated monetary scale in Equity’s summary.
Equity framed the pact as an attempt to create ground rules for actors’ images while AI develops rapidly. Its significance extends beyond the scan dispute, but the announcement does not establish how widely other productions will follow the same terms.
The immediate test is the vote among 8,000 Equity members. Approval would put project-specific consent and payment into a three-year framework for covered UK productions, while leaving the training-data question unresolved.
Source: The Guardian AI
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.
722 articles
Related articles
- Anthropic asks Australia for opt-out AI copyright model as ABC objects
- Australian poll finds 78% support consent for AI training
- Australia’s AI Copyright Debate Faces a Section 51 Test
- Disney and OpenAI Strike Deal Bringing 200+ Characters to Sora
- Adobe Presses Regulators Worldwide for New AI Creator Rights