Policy & Regulation

NJ Governor Sherrill: X Is a Bubble and States Will Regulate AI

New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill says Elon Musk's X gives Republicans a false read on voters, and pledges state action on AI, data centers and privacy in lieu of federal rules.

Why NJ’s governor thinks Republicans are trapped in an X bubble
Why NJ’s governor thinks Republicans are trapped in an X bubbleAllen & Ginter / The Met · CC0
By James Calloway7 min read

Why it matters

  • New Jersey fined a Southern-built data center over $1 million for permitting violations.
  • New Jersey stands to receive $525 million from the multistate Meta settlement.
  • Sherrill says her race saw an 18-22 point swing in the Latino vote.
  • New Jersey set up the nation's first social media research center for parents and teachers.
  • The average teen spends 35 hours per week online, according to Sherrill.

New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill says X has become a bubble that gives Republican politicians a false picture of where voters actually stand — and she argues the 2026 midterms proved it. In a wide-ranging interview on The Verge's Decoder podcast, the first-term Democrat laid out a governing agenda that puts states, not Washington, at the center of AI and tech regulation for the next several years.

Sherrill has been governor for just under a year. She won in November 2024, launching her campaign the same month Donald Trump took the presidency, on two themes she says became the Democratic playbook this cycle: affordability and accountability. "I feel absolutely fantastic about the midterms," she said, arguing New Jersey served as the bellwether for the party's broader gains.

Why did corruption top the polls?

Corruption ranked among the leading voter concerns this cycle — number one in one CNBC poll, number two in a Guardian poll. Sherrill said she heard that anger directly, even from small business owners, and she tied it to voters' pocketbooks rather than to abstract ethics.

"It's not just corruption; it's the corruption that's costing them money," Sherrill said. She cited Trump's conduct in the Iranian war, his move to allow Russian diesel imports as gas prices climbed, and semiconductor export decisions she characterized as influenced by payments from the UAE. She offered no evidence beyond public reporting for the specific allegations, and the interview did not press her on them.

The backdrop matters for the tech industry: voters angry about corruption are angry at billionaires who own the platforms. "People are very upset at the tech billionaires, and when they're hanging out at the White House, especially those flip-floppers," Sherrill said. "It's just to make a buck."

Is Elon Musk's X losing its political grip?

Decoder host Nilay Patel argued that Musk's purchase of Twitter was "a failure across every dimension" — smaller, less profitable, and politically diminished. Sherrill agreed that X distorts political reality.

She said her campaign had to learn the term "astroturf" — manufactured grassroots energy that looks organic online. The lesson: if you campaign in person constantly, you can tell whether social media sentiment matches real voters. "There is a sense that what is going on, especially, I would say on X, can give you this false sense of a bubble, and a false sense of where people are at," she said.

She pointed to recent posts by JD Vance distancing himself from Trump and a Hegseth video daring opponents to impeach as tone-deaf relics of 2024. "That bravado feels so 2024," she said, arguing young men drawn to the MAGA movement are moving away as jobs and housing stay out of reach.

On influencer politics more broadly, Sherrill called New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani "a social media prodigy" whose authenticity cannot simply be copied. She was cooler on politicians who perform toughness online. "Sometimes I curse like a sailor. I do not like to do that online," she said, citing her Navy background and her role as a mother. "Kids are online."

What can states do about AI and data centers?

The policy core of the interview was federalism. With the House having passed a 10-year moratorium on state-level AI policy earlier in Trump's term — and no meaningful federal tech regulation in sight — Sherrill said governors are exercising power that has gone untested for decades.

Her proof point: Russian diesel. When Trump moved to import it, Sherrill put every New Jersey port and business on notice that the imports violated existing federal law, charted the statutes, and reminded companies the statute of limitations runs five years. "We've seen a couple of ships turn away," she said. "If somebody had told you that the state of New Jersey could turn back the president from importing oil into this country, you would've been skeptical."

On data centers, Sherrill announced a plan in May and signed build-out bills in August, with pillars requiring water transparency and "bring your own power." New Jersey fined one Southern-built data center over a million dollars for permitting violations — among the largest such fines in the country, she said. She also backs community benefits agreements so host towns capture value rather than sending "billions of dollars to Big Tech in Silicon Valley."

She predicted more local moratoriums until the industry proves its model. "I don't think data centers have shown a model where communities are confident that if they build in their community, they are not going to be harmed," she said.

Her diagnosis of the AI debate is that government has simply been absent. "You have a government that is supposed to be there to protect people, to protect them from the downside risks. The government is nowhere to be found in this space," she said.

How is New Jersey approaching kids and social media?

Sherrill's social media laws deliberately target addictive and compulsive algorithmic design rather than content, a legal strategy built to survive First Amendment challenges after a decade of court fights. New Jersey also just established the first social media research center in the nation, partly because the underlying data is scarce — social media companies, she said, keep shutting down their own studies "because the data is so bad," which has hamstrung state lawsuits.

She was blunt about parental controls. "It would be a full-time job if I wanted to keep up with the parental controls for my kids," she said, noting the average teen spends 35 hours per week online. She got cell phones out of New Jersey schools — earning "a standing ovation from teachers," if not her own children's thanks.

Her reference point: Silicon Valley parents she met in 2017-2018 who sent their kids to screen-free schools. "Those were the people developing algorithms, and those were the people that understood the brain science," she said.

What happens after the Meta settlement?

New Jersey stands to receive $525 million from the Meta settlement, with the remainder of the national deal contingent on TikTok and YouTube agreeing to the same terms. YouTube CEO Neal Mohan has publicly declined. Sherrill expects litigation. "We've just not seen anybody move in this space willingly," she said.

She extended the argument to AI, suggesting Dario Amodei publishes regulatory prescriptions but does not adopt them unilaterally because doing so would cost Anthropic market share. Asked about Mark Zuckerberg's claim that markets will punish unsafe AI products, she answered flatly: "I know it's his argument; I just don't buy it."

She rejected the framing that social media regulation failed and AI regulation will succeed, and said the Meta settlement is not the end of litigation — multi-state cases, she noted, are coordinated by a lead state with attorneys general working collectively, and could eventually produce a Supreme Court-level standard if Congress stays frozen.

Where does privacy land in the AI era?

The conversation closed on surveillance. Sherrill declined to condemn Flock license plate readers outright — communities demanded them during New Jersey's car theft and home invasion wave, and the state audits retention and use — but she voiced unease about AI supercharging the data. "It was already a problem. And now it's not a who; it's a what. What's AI going to do with this data?" she said.

Asked about the Apple Watch feature that summarizes conversations, she rattled off unanswered questions: where the summaries go, who sees them, who can hack them. "That's why I'm not wearing an Apple Watch," she said. She said she could envision states creating new zones of expected privacy — banning cameras in certain public spaces — but acknowledged the tension with safety concerns, including attacks on women on college campuses.

Asked whether she would push the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact over the finish line with new Democratic legislatures, Sherrill was eager. "I hate the Electoral College. I've got to tell you, I love this idea," she said. "Today might be the day."

The through-line of the interview: with Washington frozen, a bloc of Democratic governors — California, Texas, New York, New Jersey — intends to set the effective rules for AI, data centers, and online safety, and Sherrill believes Tuesday's results just made that bloc considerably stronger.

Source: theverge.com

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

722 articles

Related articles

  1. Data Center Opponent Will Lawrence Heads to Congress With a Moratorium Plan
  2. Data-Center Construction Jumped 90% in September. Voters Just Pushed Back.
  3. 76 Percent of Mainers Oppose Data Centers — and It May Decide the Senate
  4. Silicon Valley's AI Political Machine Spent $78.5 Million Fighting Itself
  5. Trump disputes midterms as Nvidia chip probe draws scrutiny

« Previous articleNext article »