IBM Index: 94% of Enterprises Hit by Digital Sovereignty Issues
IBM's new Digital Sovereignty Index finds 94% of enterprises hit sovereignty challenges in three years, with AI the top trigger at 44% and only 26% able to prove control.

Why it matters
- 94% of 2,003 surveyed enterprises faced at least one digital sovereignty challenge in the past three years
- 82% of executives expressed confidence in demonstrating sovereign control, but only 26% reached the index's highest evidence tier
- AI-related issues were the most cited challenge at 44%, ahead of audits (38%) and provider changes (35%)
- Only 33% of firms continuously or regularly test their ability to demonstrate sovereignty
- 52% of top-tier enterprises resolved their hardest sovereignty challenge without material disruption, versus 22% of early-stage firms
Ninety-four percent of enterprises faced at least one digital sovereignty challenge in the past three years, according to a new IBM survey of 2,003 senior decision-makers at large companies. IBM announced the findings on November 16, 2026, alongside the launch of its Digital Sovereignty Index, a benchmark designed to measure whether organizations can retain and prove control over critical AI, technology, operations and data.
The stakes are straightforward. Regulators, customers, auditors and boards increasingly demand formal evidence that companies control their AI systems, data and operations — and most firms cannot produce it. Among organizations affected by sovereignty challenges, 81% were required to provide formal evidence of control to regulators, customers, auditors or internal stakeholders.
What does the index actually measure?
IBM defines digital sovereignty as an organization's ability to retain and prove control across critical AI, technology, operations and data, including when conditions change or external dependencies come under pressure.
The index scores companies across six areas of evidence:
- Responsibility — whether a company can show accountability for decisions
- Trace — whether it can reconstruct events
- Constraint — whether it can prove controls worked
- Intervention — whether it can explain responses
- Legitimacy — whether it can justify decisions
- Exit — whether it can demonstrate the ability to change provider or recover operations
The framing matters because it shifts sovereignty from an abstract geopolitical concern into a measurable operational discipline. The survey covered the United States, United Kingdom, Germany, France, Saudi Arabia, India and Japan, and was supported by interviews with policymakers, regulators, public-sector officials, policy experts and customer leaders.
How wide is the gap between confidence and proof?
The central finding is a stark divide between what executives believe and what they can demonstrate. On average, 82% of respondents said they were very or extremely confident they could demonstrate sovereign control. Only 26% reached the index's highest tier for evidence of that control.
That 56-percentage-point gap defines the problem IBM is putting a stake in. Boards may believe control exists, but when scrutiny arrives — from a regulator, an auditor or a customer — belief does not substitute for records, tested recovery plans or documented accountability.
Jonathan Adashek, senior vice president and chief global affairs officer at IBM, framed the issue as a question of preserving room for action when business risks turn into sovereignty risks.
"Sovereignty should expand future choices, not restrict them," Adashek said.
"When a business issue turns into a sovereignty risk, boards need to show real control: how they can adapt, change strategy or critical provider, and where freedom to act lies. The choices they make today matter, and the stakes are high. Getting this right can help them minimize shocks, keep their options open and stay competitive."
Why is AI the leading pressure point?
AI-related issues topped the list of individual sovereignty challenges, cited by 44% of respondents. The problems ranged across incorrect outputs, explainability failures, model or provider outages, and governance concerns.
The full ranking of reported challenges shows how layered the pressure has become:
- AI-related issues — 44% of respondents
- Formal audit or regulatory events — 38%
- Significant provider changes — 35%
- Data access or transfer issues — 33%
- Government restrictions, such as export controls or sanctions — 30%
AI's position at the top signals a shift. Sovereignty debates once centered on where data physically resides and which legal jurisdiction governs it. The index shows the pressure has moved up the stack, into models, outputs and providers — the components enterprises now depend on to run core operations.
External voices in the study reinforced that reading. Emmanuel Frenehard, chief digital officer at Sanofi, said sovereignty concerns are now tied directly to business continuity as AI becomes embedded across large organizations.
"Digital sovereignty is not a compliance checkbox, it's a business reality," Frenehard said.
"As AI becomes embedded across the enterprise, thinking through the many layers of sovereignty is a matter of business continuity in an age where technology is essential to run an enterprise and continue building trust."
Why do so few companies test their sovereignty arrangements?
Routine testing remains rare. Only 33% of respondents said they continuously or regularly test their ability to demonstrate sovereignty as part of governance and assurance processes.
That shortfall separates leaders from laggards more sharply than any other factor in the study. Among enterprises in the index's leading tier, 63% said they regularly or continuously tested their ability to demonstrate sovereignty. The figure fell to 29% among companies still establishing evidence, and to 9% among those at the earliest stage.
The barriers to producing proof are operational, not strategic. More than half of respondents, 56%, cited manual or time-consuming evidence collection. Another 53% pointed to fragmented evidence across teams and systems, reliance on third parties for records, and legacy systems or inconsistent standards. Half said their controls, recovery arrangements or exit plans were untested.
The pattern suggests companies know what sovereignty requires in principle but lack the plumbing — automated evidence collection, integrated records, tested exit plans — to prove it on demand.
Does stronger evidence actually reduce disruption?
The index draws a direct line between evidence practices and operational resilience. Among enterprises in the leading tier, 52% resolved their most difficult sovereignty challenge without material disruption. Among those still building their arrangements, the figure was 22%.
The implication is that companies with better-documented controls, tested recovery processes and clearer accountability structures contain operational fallout more effectively when a sovereignty issue emerges. Sovereignty proof, in other words, correlates with fewer shocks rather than more paperwork.
The research suggests businesses are being pushed to treat digital sovereignty as more than a technical or compliance issue. Companies that cannot show who was accountable for decisions, what happened during an incident, whether controls were functioning, and whether they could switch providers or restore operations face operational disruption as a concrete risk — not a theoretical one.
What comes next?
Adashek argued the next phase is not more governance but demonstrable proof that governance works.
"Companies prioritizing sovereignty are rightly planning for control, but the leaders plan for proof too. The next step is not simply more governance or regulation. It is stronger evidence that the governance works: testing exit capabilities, understanding critical dependencies and focusing efforts where a loss of control would have the greatest impact," Adashek said.
With AI now the single most common sovereignty challenge — ahead of audits, provider changes and government restrictions — the index points to a market where evidence of control over AI systems becomes a competitive differentiator. The 26% of enterprises already operating at the index's highest evidence tier have, by IBM's own data, a measurable resilience advantage: they are more than twice as likely as early-stage firms to weather their hardest sovereignty incidents without material disruption.
Source: itbrief.com.au
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.
617 articles
Related articles
- PwC survey: AI accountability scattered, 11% say it's unclear
- Nearly 60% of Legal Leaders Say AI Is Outrunning Governance
- Knightcorp report warns tech insurers leave AI and cloud claims uncovered
- Over 1,000 State AI Bills in 2025, and No Rulebook to Reconcile Them
- BlackFog survey: 47% report sensitive data exposure via AI