College Campuses Are Dumping Flock Safety Cameras Over Privacy
Cornell, Emory, Penn State and Stanford cut Flock Safety contracts as student protests grow; a research paper puts Flock's school deployments at around 150. Flock says customers own their data.

Why it matters
- Cornell, Emory, Penn State and Stanford have discontinued Flock Safety contracts, per The Guardian.
- A research paper in Policing & Society puts Flock's school deployments at around 150.
- University of Iowa students delivered 2,000 petition signatures against Flock to campus police.
- Stanford replaced Flock with Genetec technology that stores data for only one hour and shares nothing with third parties.
- Flock says its LPR cameras don't use facial recognition and can't identify who is inside a vehicle.
Cornell, Emory, Penn State and Stanford have all walked away from contracts with Flock Safety, turning college campuses into the newest flashpoint in the fight over automated surveillance. According to a recent story in The Guardian, dozens of schools — mostly college campuses — have discontinued Flock contracts or face student pressure to do so. The shift follows a year of similar backlash in cities including Los Angeles and Dayton, Ohio, where agencies reevaluated or canceled contracts for license plate readers and drones.
Flock Safety, based in Atlanta, is one of several companies — alongside Axon Enterprise, Motorola Solutions and Palantir Technologies — selling surveillance hardware and software to law enforcement. It has drawn heavy criticism for license plate reader failure rates and for abuses within law enforcement, including cases where officers inappropriately accessed collected data. The company declined to tell CNET how many colleges or schools it works with, but a recent research paper published in Policing & Society put the number at around 150.
That figure matters because campus deployments aren't the same as police cameras on a public street. Students often live where the cameras watch, many of them are minors, and the rules governing what schools can do differ from those binding city police.
What happened at Stanford?
At Stanford, a student coalition called Safe Stanford organized successfully to convince university officials to cut ties with Flock. The university didn't simply remove the cameras. It switched to technology from Genetec, which stores data for only an hour and doesn't share information with third parties.
That substitution is the detail worth watching. It shows administrators responding to privacy objections not by abandoning surveillance altogether, but by choosing systems with shorter retention and no third-party data sharing. In short: the debate on campus is less about whether to watch and more about how long records live and who else can see them.
How are students pushing back?
The most recent protests have surfaced at the University of Iowa and the University of Kentucky. At Iowa, students delivered 2,000 petition signatures to campus police. At Kentucky, student groups chanted: "Flock out! Flock off!"
The pattern mirrors what happened in municipal settings over the past year. When communities in Los Angeles and Dayton, Ohio, reconsidered surveillance contracts, the pressure came from residents and local officials. On campuses, students supply the same pressure, and administrations — which answer to their communities in ways police departments often don't — have proved willing to act.
The takeaway: organized student activism has now produced concrete contract cancellations at multiple major universities.
What does Flock say?
In an email to CNET, a Flock spokesperson stressed that customers the company contracts with own and control their own data.
"Students deserve to feel safe at school, and Flock license plate reader technology has a measurable impact on helping to solve crimes and increase public safety," the spokesperson said. "Flock LPR cameras capture a point-in-time image of the rear of a vehicle. Flock does not use facial recognition, cannot identify who is inside a vehicle and cannot determine who the vehicle is registered to."
The company is drawing a sharp line between its license plate readers and facial recognition systems, which face far broader restrictions. Its argument is that photographing the back of a car is a narrow, crime-solving tool — not a system for tracking people. Critics argue the aggregate effect is the same: a database of where vehicles go becomes a database of where people go.
Why are campus cameras legally different?
When police departments or county sheriff's offices deploy Flock, they typically install cameras in public locations, pointing them at street intersections or mounting them on buildings. College and high school campuses play by different rules. They may have their own policies for on-campus surveillance, and public schools can be bound by state laws that also apply to government agencies.
"Campuses also raise issues ordinary public streets don't: students often live there, many are minors, and student-privacy laws and school-search rules vary by state, as do limits on how long plate data can be kept and shared," said Amy Peikoff, an attorney for the Pacific Legal Foundation.
Peikoff said most courts have allowed the collection of the types of data Flock Safety gathers. The legal friction, in her view, comes later — in how long agencies such as police departments or schools retain what they collect. Activists have previously documented abuses in which law enforcement workers inappropriately accessed or shared Flock data, in some cases using it for stalking.
Peikoff didn't mince words about the retention question:
"Maintaining a vast, queryable database of location histories of individuals about whom there's no particularized suspicion not only presents an opportunity for abuse, but is in itself, I believe, a Fourth Amendment violation."
That's a contested legal claim — courts have largely tolerated this kind of collection — but it frames the core dispute. The problem isn't the camera on the pole. It's the searchable record it feeds.
What comes next?
The campus movement is still accelerating. With roughly 150 school deployments documented in academic research and a growing list of cancellations, Flock now faces a customer base that includes some of the most organized privacy advocates in the country: students who live under the cameras full-time.
Stanford's switch to Genetec — one-hour retention, no third-party sharing — offers a template other administrations can copy without giving up surveillance entirely. Expect the next phase of this fight to focus less on the presence of cameras and more on data retention limits, sharing rules, and who gets queried the database.
Source: cnet.com
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.
749 articles
Related articles
- Flock Safety to cut roughly 270 jobs, 18% of workforce
- Flock, Not Its CEO, Faces the Senate Over Its 'AI Surveillance Network'
- Flock CEO Claims Its Microphones Detect 'Just Gunshots.' The Website Disagrees
- AI-Powered Worker Surveillance Draws Privacy Warnings in Australia
- Adversarial Fashion Takes Aim at AI Surveillance Cameras