Companies

Chip Scare Drove Alibaba Down 41% This Year. PDD Offers a Cheaper Bet

Alibaba is down 41.2% this year on AI chip access fears; PDD, reporting the same day, trades at 8× earnings with $67.7 billion in cash against Alibaba's negative free cash flow.

Alibaba Got Hit by the Chip Scare. Is PDD a Safer Alternative?
Alibaba Got Hit by the Chip Scare. Is PDD a Safer Alternative?geralt / pixabay
By Rebecca Stone5 min read

Why it matters

  • Alibaba trades at $86.65, down 14.7% in a week and 41.2% year to date; PDD trades at $77.39, down 32.0% YTD.
  • Alibaba's Q1 AI Cloud revenue rose 45% to $7.1 billion, but free cash flow was negative $6.6 billion on capex up 75% to $9.9 billion.
  • PDD holds $67.7 billion in cash and short-term investments, about 61% of its $110.2 billion market cap.
  • The Remote Access Security Act passed the House in January and would let the Commerce Department oversee remote cloud access to restricted chips.
  • Appaloosa sold 150,000 Alibaba shares in the quarter ended Sept. 30, 2026, keeping 1,850,000, per its Nov. 16 13F.

Alibaba (NYSE: BABA) trades at $86.65, down 14.7% in one week and 41.2% year to date, while PDD Holdings (NASDAQ: PDD) trades at $77.39, down 2.1% in a week and 32.0% year to date. Both Chinese internet giants report earnings before the U.S. market opens on Nov. 19, and the gap between their stock charts is the story of how Washington's chip policy is repricing China's AI ambitions.

The proximate trigger was a chip controversy. Quartz, citing Bloomberg, reported that Alibaba's Hong Kong-listed shares fell as much as 7.3% on Nov. 12 on fears that Washington could tighten China's access to advanced AI chips. The fears follow a controversy involving the CEO of Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA) and Singapore-based Megaspeed International.

Bloomberg reported that Alibaba leases Nvidia chips through Megaspeed, which has rejected claims that it illegally rerouted chips to China. China has denied related spying allegations.

What does the chip affair change in Washington?

Chinese cloud providers worry the affair could revive the Remote Access Security Act. The bill would let the Commerce Department oversee remote, cloud-based access to restricted chips. It passed the House in January; the Senate has not moved.

House committee leaders asked Nvidia's CEO to attend a Nov. 18 briefing, per CNBC. For Alibaba, the legislative threat lands directly on the input its AI buildout depends on: Nvidia silicon leased through intermediaries.

The stakes for the broader market are straightforward. U.S. export controls were designed to keep advanced AI chips out of China; a rental loophole routed through third parties shows why enforcement has struggled. Any move to regulate cloud-based chip access would raise the cost and risk of every AI compute project in China, and Alibaba is the most exposed large cap.

Whose growth is stronger going into Nov. 19?

Alibaba's fiscal first-quarter revenue reached $39.64 billion, with AI Cloud revenue up 45% to $7.1 billion. CEO Eddie Wu said AI-related product revenue delivered "triple-digit growth for the twelfth consecutive quarter." China customer management revenue fell 7% in the same quarter.

Analysts have raised their view of Alibaba's September quarter. The EPS consensus for the quarter moved to 11.0254 in local currency, up from 9.8235 some 90 days ago.

PDD's numbers are slower but steadier. Second-quarter revenue rose 8.1% to $16.7 billion. GAAP net income fell 12% to $4.03 billion. Its September-quarter consensus of 18.8414 has barely moved from 18.5751 some 90 days ago.

Alibaba wins on cloud momentum. PDD wins on predictability — analysts have barely touched their estimates, while Alibaba's revision history reflects a business in transition from e-commerce to AI infrastructure.

Why does valuation favor PDD so heavily?

At a $110.2 billion market cap, PDD trades at roughly 8× fiscal 2025 net income of $14.5 billion. Alibaba, at $215.56 billion market cap, trades near 15× fiscal 2026 net income of $14.8 billion. PDD trades at about half Alibaba's earnings multiple.

The balance sheet gap is wider. PDD holds $67.7 billion in cash and short-term investments — about 61% of its market value. It pays no dividend and has no disclosed buyback, but the cash cushion offers a margin of safety that a small yield cannot match.

Alibaba paid $1.05 per American depositary share for fiscal 2026, a yield near 1.2%, and holds a $19.1 billion buyback authorization. Actual buybacks tell a different story: the company repurchased only $162 million of stock last quarter.

How much risk does Alibaba's AI capex carry?

Alibaba's capital expenditure rose 75% to $9.9 billion in the quarter, pushing free cash flow to negative $6.6 billion. Debt to EBITDA doubled to 2.29×. Every dollar of that spending depends on chip access now under Washington scrutiny — the direct link between the Nov. 12 selloff and the fundamentals.

PDD's exposure runs through Temu rather than compute. Co-CEO Lei Chen said, "global trade and regulatory landscapes have continued to evolve, creating significant challenges." Beijing's regulators oversee both companies.

Earnings-day history punishes both stocks, in different ways. Across seven reports, Alibaba averaged a 1.9% one-day gain. Across six reports, PDD averaged a 4.2% report-day decline. PDD swings harder on the day itself, but its unlevered balance sheet absorbs shocks that Alibaba's leveraged AI expansion cannot.

What are big investors doing?

David Tepper's Appaloosa sold 150,000 Alibaba shares in the quarter ended Sept. 30, 2026, and held 1,850,000 shares as of that date, per its 13F filed Nov. 16. One hedge fund's trimming is not a verdict, but it marks the direction of institutional caution ahead of the print.

Which stock screens better for retirement savers?

On the source analysis, PDD screens stronger on valuation and balance sheet. The case rests on four numbers:

  • Roughly 8× earnings versus roughly 15× for Alibaba
  • $67.7 billion in cash and short-term investments, about 61% of market value
  • $15.3 billion in fiscal 2025 operating cash flow
  • No dividend or buyback, but no leveraged capex program either

Alibaba's counterargument is growth: 45% AI Cloud revenue expansion, twelve consecutive quarters of triple-digit AI product revenue growth, and rising analyst estimates. The cost is negative $6.6 billion in quarterly free cash flow and a chip supply chain that Congress may restrict further.

What would change the comparison?

The analysis sets explicit tripwires. Alibaba would need to show capex leveling off, free cash flow moving toward positive, and no new disruption to chip access. PDD would lose its edge if Transaction Services growth slows well below its 13% pace, or if Temu takes new trade hits that eat into the cash cushion.

The Nov. 19 reports will test both. Alibaba must convince investors that a 75% capex surge has a visible payoff under tightening chip rules; PDD must show that $67.7 billion in cash still compounding matters more than a 4.2% average earnings-day drop.

Source: 247wallst.com

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

754 articles

Related articles

  1. Alibaba Drops 8% as U.S. Nears Rule Blocking Remote AI Chip Access
  2. Nvidia Chips Reach China's AI Labs Through a Legal Rental Route
  3. Nvidia Loses $430 Billion as CEO Affair and China Chip Claims Escalate
  4. Nvidia Faces $400 Billion Two-Day Wipeout Over CEO Affair Allegations
  5. Nvidia Trades 18% Down as Washington Adds a Governance Discount

« Previous articleNext article »