Policy & Regulation

Cantwell accuses Commerce of giving away America's AI edge

Senator Maria Cantwell says Commerce has "undermined America's national security" by letting Nvidia's AI chips reach Chinese-linked companies and subsidiaries.

Senator slams Commerce Secretary for flow of Nvidia AI chips to China
Senator slams Commerce Secretary for flow of Nvidia AI chips to ChinaInWay / pixabay
By Elena Vasquez5 min read

Why it matters

  • Cantor Fitzgerald reportedly held $1.2 billion in Nvidia stock when Howard Lutnick was nominated Commerce Secretary.
  • Cantwell sent her letter to Lutnick on Sunday, ahead of Thursday's Trump-Xi meeting in China.
  • Lutnick is expected to designate Nvidia, OpenAI, Anthropic, Amazon and Microsoft AI "national champions" with expedited export licences, The Wall Street Journal reported.
  • Cantwell says Commerce allowed Alibaba and ByteDance to access Nvidia chips through overseas data centers.
  • Commerce reportedly did not heed White House and intelligence warnings about restricting Megaspeed's AI chip access.

By Elena Vasquez

Cantor Fitzgerald reportedly held $1.2 billion in Nvidia stock when Howard Lutnick was nominated to run the Department of Commerce. Senator Maria Cantwell put that figure into a Sunday letter to the Commerce Secretary. She wrote that his agency has "undermined America's national security."

Cantwell is a Washington senator and one of the top Democrats on the Senate commerce committee. In the letter, she said the department's failures "help give away America's technology advantage in AI." Her complaint concerns enforcement, not the absence of legal authority.

Her letter lands ahead of a Trump-Xi meeting in China, with Congress moving to tighten restrictions and Commerce preparing to promote American AI exporters abroad.

What does Cantwell accuse the Commerce Department of doing?

Cantwell's argument starts with authority Congress already granted. She wrote:

"Despite clear authority from Congress, the Department of Commerce has allowed advanced AI chips to flow through companies with ties to the People's Republic of China (PRC).

The Department of Commerce has resisted efforts to restrict companies flagged as national security threats, weakened safeguards, and left open pathways for the PRC to train advanced AI models using sensitive American technology."

That second sentence lists three failures. Commerce resisted restricting companies flagged as national security threats. It weakened safeguards. It left pathways open for the PRC to train advanced AI models on American chips.

Her complaint is not that Congress failed to write export rules, but that the agency assigned to enforce them repeatedly declined to act on warnings.

The letter names three routes she says the department left open. Each one runs through a company with a Chinese connection. She also says Commerce ignored warnings from the White House and from intelligence officials about one chip supplier.

Why does the Megaspeed case matter?

Megaspeed comes first in Cantwell's accounting. She says the Commerce Department reportedly did not heed warnings from White House and intelligence officials to restrict Megaspeed's access to AI chips.

Those warnings came before allegations that former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang had an affair with a then-Megaspeed executive suspected of being a Chinese spy. Cantwell places the episode inside a wider Jensen Huang fallout, and she uses it to test whether Commerce acts when warnings arrive.

For Cantwell, the sequence matters more than any one person's conduct: a Commerce Department that ignored official warnings was choosing not to see the risk. Her letter treats that as an institutional failure, not an individual one.

The letter alleges no crime by Megaspeed. It makes an institutional charge. Commerce had warnings from the White House and from intelligence officials, and it did not restrict the access those warnings concerned.

Which Chinese companies does she name?

Alibaba and ByteDance come next. Cantwell says the Commerce Department allowed both companies to access Nvidia chips through overseas data centers. She also accuses the department of extending a loophole that let restricted companies obtain American AI technology through subsidiaries.

The subsidiary loophole, she writes, gave restricted companies a second path to American AI technology even after the main route to those same firms had been shut.

These are not abstract worries. They name Alibaba and ByteDance, and they describe how a parent company can reach restricted technology through a subsidiary. Cantwell's charge is that Commerce treated each route as a compliance question rather than a security one.

What is the financial criticism of Lutnick?

Cantwell also says the department has been "putting business interests ahead of national security." She points to Cantor Fitzgerald, the financial services firm Lutnick formerly led and that his sons now steer.

The letter says the firm reportedly held $1.2 billion in Nvidia stock at the time of Lutnick's nomination for Commerce Secretary. The figure puts a number on the ties between the secretary and the chipmaker at issue.

Cantwell's argument is about priority, and the letter uses a former employer's shareholding to argue that Commerce has not consistently put national security controls first.

The letter makes no allegation about how the firm acquired or sold those shares, and it does not describe the stake as a trade in Nvidia stock. It uses the holdings to argue about the agency's priorities.

What is the "national champion" initiative?

Commerce is preparing something with the opposite emphasis. The Wall Street Journal reported that Lutnick is expected to unveil a new initiative designating Nvidia, along with OpenAI, Anthropic, Amazon, and Microsoft, as an AI "national champion."

The designation reportedly aims to help those companies expand overseas and compete with Chinese technology firms. The mechanism is faster paperwork: expedited export licence approvals. Congress is looking to bolster export restrictions around AI chips.

A national champion designation would give the five named companies a faster route through the export licensing system than competitors outside the United States would receive.

The list pairs a chipmaker with four major AI developers, according to the report. The stakes are commercial as much as strategic. The initiative is meant to help American firms expand overseas and compete with Chinese technology firms, and the approvals would come from the same agency Cantwell says failed to police the China trade.

What does the letter leave unanswered?

The letter names companies, channels, and failures. It does not put dates on the warnings, count the chips that moved, or attach a dollar value to the transfers it describes.

It also does not say what Commerce did with the allegations once they reached the agency, or whether the department opened an inquiry into any firm named. Cantwell's demand is for an accounting, and she leaves the format of that accounting to the administration.

What happens before Thursday?

Trump and Xi meet in China this Thursday. Cantwell wants the Commerce Department to explain its enforcement record before the administration hands out faster licences.

"America cannot maintain its leadership in AI if the agency responsible for protecting that advantage fails to enforce its own controls. The Administration must account for its failure to enforce these protections and take immediate action to prevent America's most sensitive technology from strengthening our adversaries."

The administration's answer will show which way Commerce leans when a security control and an export promotion pull in opposite directions. Cantwell's letter puts that choice in writing days before Trump and Xi meet, with the firms she named still waiting to see whether the routes she described get closed.

Source: theverge.com

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

708 articles

Related articles

  1. Lutnick to testify before Senate over Nvidia China chip sales
  2. Senators demand preservation of NVIDIA records over alleged spy ties
  3. Nvidia's Huang Agrees to House Interviews Over China Chip Sales
  4. Bessent faults Commerce over delayed Nvidia China chip controls
  5. Nvidia Loses $430 Billion as CEO Affair and China Chip Claims Escalate

« Previous articleNext article »