Companies

AI Answers Now Rank Australia's Lenders — and Challengers Are Winning

Third Hemisphere's first AI Authority Index ranks 124 Australian lenders on how AI engines name and judge them, with CommBank and NAB topping a CRISP score of 54 while challengers beat big banks on reputation.

AI index ranks Aussie lenders as challengers beat banks
AI index ranks Aussie lenders as challengers beat banksIqbalStock / pixabay
By Elena Vasquez5 min read

Why it matters

  • CommBank and NAB recorded the joint-highest CRISP score of 54 in the first AI Authority Index: Personal Lending.
  • The index draws on 195,689 AI answers across seven AI engines, logging 1,526,848 brand mentions and 60,206 companies.
  • ING and OurMoneyMarket scored 69 on Reputation, ahead of NAB (60), Westpac (56) and ANZ (42).
  • ANZ was the only lender categorised as "AI Infamous" on the index's Star Chart.
  • Third Hemisphere estimates the Australian personal lending market at AUD $168 billion and says 87 per cent of Australians use AI search for financial decisions.

CommBank and NAB top the first ever index of how AI engines rank Australian lenders, scoring a joint-high CRISP score of 54 — but smaller challengers including ING, OurMoneyMarket and Plenti beat three of the big four banks on reputation. Marketing agency Third Hemisphere published the AI Authority Index: Personal Lending, the first edition of a ranking that measures how often AI systems name lenders and whether those systems recommend or caution against them. The headline finding: scale no longer guarantees favourability when Australians ask an AI engine which lender to trust.

The stakes are straightforward. Third Hemisphere estimates the Australian personal lending market at AUD $168 billion, and cites research showing 87 per cent of Australians use AI search in financial services purchasing decisions. When someone asks ChatGPT for a lender, the answer shapes their shortlist before they ever reach a comparison site or a bank's own website.

How the index was built

The model draws on a large evidence base: 195,689 AI answers across 159 sectors and seven AI engines, logging 1,526,848 brand mentions covering 60,206 distinct companies. For the personal lending edition, the agency analysed 166 questions spanning personal loans, debt consolidation, car finance, credit cards and short-term credit.

The questions covered five stages of a borrower's decision-making process. None of them named a lender, which matters — the index measures spontaneous visibility in unbranded queries, not responses to "tell me about CommBank."

The published results list 124 lenders named by AI engines. Of those, only 28 made the leaderboard with a CRISP score. The other 96 were classed as under the radar, mentioned too infrequently for a reliable score.

What does a CRISP score actually measure?

Third Hemisphere used a five-factor methodology known as CRISP. It combines:

  • Consensus (10 per cent) — how consistently AI engines name a company
  • Reputation (25 per cent) — whether recommendations outweigh cautions
  • Influence (25 per cent) — how many independent sources support what the engines say
  • Source (15 per cent) — whether a company's own website is readable and reliable for AI systems
  • Presence (25 per cent) — how often a company is named in unbranded queries

CommBank posted the highest Presence score at 46 and the highest Reputation score on the leaderboard at 71. In plain terms, AI engines both mention and recommend it relatively often.

Where the challengers beat the big banks

Beyond the big banks, the index found a weaker link between scale and recommendation strength. ING and OurMoneyMarket each scored 69 on Reputation. Plenti scored 68, Harmoney 67 and NOW Finance 66.

Those results put the challengers ahead of NAB on 60, Westpac on 56 and ANZ on 42 for that measure — despite the major banks appearing more often in AI-generated answers. The findings suggest visibility and favourability do not always move together in AI search results. Being famous with the engines is not the same as being liked by them.

The Star Chart: from "AI Famous" to "Off the Guest List"

The agency grouped lenders into six bands on what it calls a Star Chart, based on how often they are named and whether AI systems recommend them more often than they warn against them.

  • AI Famous: CommBank, NAB and Westpac
  • Rising Star: ING and Macquarie
  • Cult Favourite: 15 lenders, including Plenti, OurMoneyMarket and Harmoney
  • AI Infamous: ANZ — the only lender in this band, named often but cautioned against more than recommended
  • Off the Guest List: Cash Converters, BOQ, Latitude Financial Services, St.George, Nimble and Resimac — named less often and viewed negatively when they did appear

Well-known consumer finance and payments brands had little presence in the sample. Afterpay, Zip, Klarna, Revolut, Virgin Money and American Express were all named in fewer than 30 answers, leaving them without a CRISP score in this edition.

Who actually influences the engines?

The index also found comparison sites such as Finder and Canstar were particularly influential when borrowers were close to choosing a lender. That points to a distribution of influence in which AI engines draw on third-party information sources rather than relying only on lenders' own websites or brand recognition.

Jeremy Liddle, executive chair of Third Hemisphere, built the index and co-founded AI reputation company Contrlr with Tony Surtees. He said the model was designed to measure how AI systems describe companies relative to their peers.

"The good news for every lender is that those sources can be influenced," Liddle said in the report. "The engines form their opinions from comparison sites, ranking sites, regulators, and the media, so companies that earn real coverage, engage those sources well, and publish facts people can rely on can earn their way into the answers."

He added: "The stakes are only rising. AI engines now sit between Australians and the decisions they make about their money, and when someone asks ChatGPT which lender to trust, the answer shapes their shortlist before they visit a comparison site or a bank's website."

One disclosed overlap sits in the results: MONEYME, a Third Hemisphere client, appears on the leaderboard, and the agency published its readings unchanged.

What the founders say comes next

Liddle framed the index as both a measurement tool and a commercial play. "Authentic leadership is the future of marketing," he said. "I built the CRISP technology so Third Hemisphere could help Australian brands lead the world, and so every Australian company can see how the AI engines describe it, with the tools and support to improve its standing."

Hannah Moreno, founder and chief executive officer of Third Hemisphere, linked the results to AI's shifting role in consumer trust. "Trust has been the currency of financial services long before I founded Third Hemisphere in 2014 with MONEYME as our first client," Moreno said. "What is different now is the AI engines decide who deserves this trust as guardians of the information we consume about brands."

Her reading of the first index splits the market into two jobs. "Challengers already win the engines' trust when they're found, so their task is to be found more often, while three of the big four need to change what the engines say about them," Moreno said. "Both are fixable, and we're happy to show any lender how."

The index's implicit pitch is that AI visibility is now manageable, scoreable and sellable — and with 96 lenders currently under the radar and ANZ carrying the solo "AI Infamous" label, plenty of Australian finance brands now have a number they want to move.

Source: itbrief.com.au

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

708 articles

Related articles

  1. AI Index: Australian Challenger Lenders Beat Big Banks on Trust
  2. Australia's loan AI talks. Humans still make the decisions.
  3. Splendid Finance launches AI business loan finder covering 175 Australian lenders
  4. AI Assistants Now Write the B2B Shortlist — and 60% of the Lists They Trust Are Competitors' Own Posts
  5. Community banks are deliberately slow-walking AI adoption

« Previous articleNext article »