Policy & Regulation

A Million Young Britons Are Neet — and Milburn Says Employers Hold the Fix

Alan Milburn's report demands benefit cuts for under-25s and a legal jobs guarantee. But 40% of Britain's unemployed are young, and employers are not hiring them.

Firms need to get onside if Labour’s youth employment push is to have a chance of working | Richard Partington
Firms need to get onside if Labour’s youth employment push is to have a chance of working | Richard PartingtonAI-generated
By James Calloway6 min read

Why it matters

  • Almost 1 million young Britons are not in education, employment or training (Neet).
  • Under-25 unemployment is rising at the fastest rate since 2008; young people make up about 40% of all unemployment.
  • For every £1 spent on job support, £25 goes on benefits, Milburn's report finds.
  • Youth jobseekers in Rotherham face a sixfold opportunity gap versus peers in the Cotswolds.
  • Never-employed 24-year-olds stand to lose up to £300,000 in lifetime earnings.

By James Calloway

Almost a million young people in Britain are not in education, employment or training (Neet) — and this week's landmark report from Alan Milburn will argue that employers, not just the state, decide whether that number falls. The report calls for benefit cuts for under-25s in exchange for a legal guarantee of a job or training, alongside changes to education and health. Implementation, Milburn concedes, will take a decade.

The backdrop is stark. Unemployment among under-25s has risen at the fastest rate since the 2008 financial crisis and now sits at its highest level relative to the workforce of all ages since the early 1990s. Young people account for roughly 40% of all unemployment in Britain. Last week, Bank of England deputy governor Clare Lombardelli said young people were bearing the brunt of a "low-gear economy", with employers freezing recruitment amid the war in the Middle East.

Why the current system is failing?

Milburn's sharpest statistic: for every £1 spent on job support, £25 goes on benefits. That imbalance anchors his case that the system directs money toward sustaining joblessness rather than ending it. It is a compelling ratio — but it describes state spending patterns, not the causes of youth unemployment.

The report itself carries caveats, and they matter. Half of all Neets are not on benefits at all, which limits how much welfare policy can reach. Bad jobs and a lack of entry-level opportunities are far bigger drivers of Britain's youth jobs crisis than the generosity of the benefits system. Benefit conditionality, in other words, treats a symptom.

The entry-level problem has been two decades in the making. The Saturday job died long ago, and the positions at the start of the career ladder are now the ones most at risk of automation or replacement by AI. The regional divide compounds it: the places in Britain with the fewest job vacancies have the highest Neet rates, and young jobseekers in Rotherham face a sixfold gap in opportunity relative to their peers in the Cotswolds.

Takeaway: the state spends heavily on the consequences of youth joblessness while spending almost nothing on its causes.

What does Milburn actually propose?

The headline measure is controversial inside Labour: restricting benefits for under-25s to encourage work, paired with a legal guarantee of employment or training. Behind the argument sits a principle the party has historically struggled with — that restricting benefits to push people into work is a good idea.

When the report lands, corporate Britain will be out in force to show willing. Amazon, Marks & Spencer, Shell and Pret a Manger are among those who have already spotted the PR opportunity to showcase their efforts. Most, the analysis makes clear, are doing nowhere near enough.

The employers' preferred fixes are tax cuts, looser regulations, and holding back rises in the youth minimum wage. Policy costs are a real factor, and the state could do more to prepare young people for work — but the problems run deeper than the cost of hiring.

Takeaway: a jobs guarantee without willing employers is a legal promise with no delivery mechanism.

How do young jobseekers experience the market?

The evidence of employer behaviour is unflattering. Almost half of jobseekers under 25 surveyed by Youth Employment UK think employers are unsupportive. Application black holes are routine. Companies demand experience even for entry-level roles — the catch-22 that locks out first-time workers.

Running youth outreach programmes, work experience schemes and support for recruits who need time to get up to speed costs money, especially in tough economic times. The consequences of not doing so are increasingly visible in the numbers.

Job quality is part of the crisis. Low-paid, insecure work is rife, most notably in the places with the highest Neet rates. Over the past quarter of a century, in-work poverty has grown: the relative poverty rate among working households is now 18%, against 13% in the mid-1990s. More than one in 10 young workers are on zero-hours contracts. Employers' groups point out, fairly, that such flexibility can be welcome and act as a launchpad to a career — yet despite the gig economy boom of the past 25 years, Britain's Neet rate has fallen below 10% only once.

Takeaway: for many young people the problem is not the absence of work but the presence of work that leads nowhere.

What is the human cost?

Countless studies link badly paid, insecure work to poor mental wellbeing. Across all job types, almost 1 million people in Britain suffer from work-related stress, depression or anxiety. People in poor-quality employment are up to three times more likely to leave the workforce than those in the highest-quality positions. For the growing number of Neets already grappling with mental health problems, a labour market like this is a daunting prospect.

The attitudinal data is bleak in its own right. Job satisfaction has dropped to the lowest level recorded by the British Social Attitudes survey this month. Separate figures show most young people believe not everyone can go as far as their talent and hard work will take them. Young workers are also more likely to cycle into joblessness again within weeks of finding insecure work.

Takeaway: poor-quality jobs do not just pay badly — they push people out of the workforce altogether.

Does the participation argument hold up?

Milburn's view is that, despite these challenges, emphasising participation is unequivocally the right thing to do. With extra support, he argues, the barriers to work could be overcome. Getting a job, the case runs, beats life sitting in a bedroom doomscrolling: work can give structure, routine, social connections, status and — here's hoping — some financial security. Unemployment, by contrast, is a killer for wellbeing and financially ruinous.

The lifetime stakes are quantified. Those who reach the age of 24 without ever having had a job stand to lose up to £300,000 in lifetime earnings, even if they later re-enter the labour market successfully.

And the young are not shirkers, whatever the benefit-cut framing implies. Across society, as few as 4% of working-age adults say they would ideally prefer not to work. Among under-25s, that figure drops to 2%.

Takeaway: the desire to work is not the constraint — the structure of the market is.

What happens next?

The report lands as a defining test for Andy Burnham's government, forcing Labour to choose between a decade-long overhaul and continued drift. But the analysis is explicit on one point: fixing the social contract will require more than benefit cuts and a 10-year rebuilding of the state. There is a big job, too, for employers — and, on current evidence, most have not started it.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in artificial intelligence and machine learning at AI In Context.

604 articles

Related articles

  1. IMF's Georgieva Warns AI Is Hitting Global Jobs Like a Tsunami
  2. Australia's Central Bank Finds AI Hits Young Workers First
  3. 42% of New College Grads Are Underemployed as AI Rewrites Hiring
  4. 700 Million Won Bonuses, 47 Months of Youth Job Declines: Korea's Split Economy
  5. Meta Chief Data Officer: AI May Offset Global Population Collapse

« Previous articleNext article »